6.30.2008

Guest post by Mark Sanders

Intro from James- Mark Sanders is a name that many of you will probably recognize. I have mentioned him and his Strida design on the blog several times. In addition to the Strida, the UK based designer/ engineer has created many other interesting folding bikes. I admire his work, so I asked Mark to submit a guest post to share his thoughts about bike design. I am happy that he took the time to do so and I think you will find his post quite interesting, so without anything further from me, here is Mark’s guest post for Bicycle Design:

As a 12 year old, living in hilly Sheffield, UK, I was not in a cycling club, but I loved the personal freedom a bike gave me to explore much further (que Bob Sinclair ). My bike was like a human amplifier. By 18, girls, cars and a few years of engineering and design studies had taken over, and I didn't really ride much until the Strida project 7 years later.

I think it was an advantage to see bikes through the eyes of an occasional cyclist, as later I realised this is the untapped market .... a vast 'blue ocean' of potential cyclists, compared to the overcrowded 'red ocean' of enthusiasts where the bicycle industry tends to focus.

(This data is based on cycling capable population, and has similar proportions in many western countries)

I try and keep this perspective even after 20 years of designing and riding bikes. I approach bicycle design like other product design and engineering. It is one thing to make a product attractive, but the engineering needs to be worked out too – it's all design. The best part of my job is to dream; what would really be better? Then I enjoy the inventive challenge to make that dream real. I have little interest in doing 'me-too's' in reaction to marketing research – as Henry Ford reflected: “If I’d asked customers what they wanted, they would have said 'faster horses'.”

The Strida , originally a college project, was never intended for outright speed and racing. [Its design and development has been shown on Dezeen and Google eg this Video and pictures]. Strida was deliberately designed for urban utility use and with a riding position like upright Dutch bikes, and Copenhagen bikes it was designed to appeal to 'Blue Ocean' users, who also want a bike to be like any other contemporary product; fresh, easy to use and in this case ultra-portable (never carry – just wheel along).

See the classic Henry Drefus picture which illustrates the contrast wonderfully...... A bent neck and back work well to reduce drag for sport, but are not so good for people who just need a utility to get from A to B, easily, in comfort with good vision and without sweating !!

There are many 'Blue Ocean' Strida users in the Far East – this is a gathering of Strida riders at the Taipei show this year....

In South Korea, the 'Strida cafe' forum has 25,000 members – and probably due to a similar mix of men and women, has resulted in many friendships and several marriages. I think the popularity is due to the non-sporting, fun nature of both the bike and its riders. This is quite a contrast to the more serious, sport and testosterone fuelled western bike industry.

After several other, generally folding and structural products, (golf carts, medical transport chairs etc.) I got to work on the X-Bike for Sir Clive Sinclair [Uk's Steve Jobs of the '80's] .... with 2 tubes this was even simpler than the 3 tube strida !

This was a wonderful opportunity to do some fascinating, fundamental testing and bicycle research: solid urethane tyres, small wheels with and without suspension, hub centre steering, ultra short wheel bases, twisting front wheel drive transmissions, etc. Pictures HERE show some of the designs and testing – I learned that many of the so called 'bicycling facts' were in fact only 'de-facto' when used in context of cycle sport ... and not necessarily appropriate for everyday utility cycling. However, the planned low cost production version of the X-bike relied on fusible cored tools and injection moulded, long fibre reinforced nylon. But risks were high and the required investment disappeared. The same concept may now work with today's carbon frame techniques, but not for such a low target price. Instead, Sir Clive went on to develop the A-Bike with Alex Kalogroulis (who also worked on the X-bike).

Nowadays bikes are my primary daily transport – there is always something to test. I still believe folding bikes are a keystone in future urban transport plans; they make public transport 'door to door' to compete head on with private cars for commuting and short journeys; but why isn't everybody using folding bikes ? Even in London, with congestion charges and tube bombings bike use has increased 3 fold, but 90%+ of bikes are full-sized, non-folding bikes. These bikes are banned on public transport at peak times and are way too big to store in the office or in a car.

This lead me to dream of a new full-sized folding bike. Fast and easy folding into a small, wheel-able package, with all the mass between wheels and handle as HERE , and HERE This aims to appeal across the range of non-cyclists to cycling enthusiasts, and using standard gears, wheels etc. to leverage the fruits of 100years of bicycle component R&D. Now, after a few false starts, Pacific-Cycles have added their own considerable skills to this dream, and now own and are producing the IF (integrated folding) range of bikes. These are based around a 3 dimensional, 4 bar link which auto-tensions the frame and guides the wheels together in one folding action. Best seen in Video

Working at the Pacific factory is like being in heaven; as well as George and Michael Lin's expert team and their fantastic bike building facilities (CAD, CNC, precision welding, heat treatment etc etc.), it is a great place to meet bike designers eg Ryan Carroll, Marcus Riese, Steve Domahidy, Jay MacNeil, Chris Canfield, to name just a few.

IF Mode: was the 1st to be conceived with monoforks and a moncoque frame. It still remains close to the dream. Production versions have all enclosed chain drive with gears.

This is George Lin, Pacific's legendary Chairman [called the father of the Taiwanese bike industry] on an early IF Mode.

IF Cross: Adding IF technology to a conventional frame, using 700c wheels, all the benefits of Fast fold, wheel-able when folded and small folded size are retained with a wide choice of standard gears, wheels and other components. Video of 1st prototype

IF Reach: adds IF technology to Pacific's race winning, full suspension Reach.

The future of folding bikes - I see mechanisms getting much more like the automatic umbrellas we all now take for granted, but hidden in beautiful, clean and seamless monocoque frames. Having just turned 2 classic manual Can and Jar openers into fully automatic products, I dream of doing something similar with folding bikes.

6.27.2008

Air powered trials bike

Peter Queckenstedt is a Canadian designer currently studying for his master's degree in transportation design at the Umea Institute of Design in Sweden. He sent me sketches and renderings for a project that he recently worked on, a trials bike driven by a rotary air engine. Normally, I don’t post bike designs that are not pedal powered, but I really liked his development sketches so I decided to pass this along. The more I think about it, the compressed air engine, which is much lighter than an electric one, seems like a possible sustainable solution as a supplemental assist on a pedal powered bike. It could make a nice reserve power engine on a pedal driven commuting bike. Peter explained that “the air tank in the frame is a scaled up concept from the fiber composite tanks currently used in paintball, transport, and industry etc.” He goes on to give a little more insight into the reasoning behind his decision to design an air powered bike:

"I chose to use air power because it is a very lightweight power source when compared to electric drive. Compressed air is also an intriguing possibility for sustainable vehicles, obviously compressing air requires power, but the storage of that air requires no toxic chemicals or rare metals. Air engines like to rev quite high as well, so it seemed like a bike was the perfect showcase for this technology. I chose a trials bike because they have a very lean build, yet dramatic stance. They also do not need to travel long distances, which fit in with the air engine's shorter range than petrol or electric (though in hindsight I'd be confident that this bike could have very functional ranges for traveling)."

Interesting project; thanks to Peter for sharing it.

6.25.2008

Klunkerz

Quite some time ago, I wrote a post about Charlie Cunningham and the early aluminum mountain bikes that he designed. In a comment to that post, Billy Savage mentioned his film Klunkerz, a documentary about the early evolution of the mountain bike. I had heard of the movie before, and it seemed like something I would like, so I intended to order a copy when I read his comment. Unfortunately, I got sidetracked and forgot all about it.

Just last week, a year and a half later, Fritz at Cyclelicious posted about Klunkerz and I was reminded that I still hadn’t seen the film. As soon as I read his post, I went to the Klunkerz site and finally ordered a DVD. I am glad I did; Billy Savage did a really great job interviewing the pioneers of mountain biking and telling the story of the early days of riding on Mt Tam. My wife and I watched the movie over the weekend, and we both really enjoyed it (and she is not bike obsessed like me). The film really is well edited and entertaining, so I encourage all of you who are interested in mountain biking, or bicycle innovation in general, to order a copy.

Mountain bikes have changed quite a bit since I bought my first one in the mid to late eighties and even that old bike was technologically way ahead of the pre war Schwinn newsboys that those guys were riding on Repack in the 70s. After watching Klunkerz, any of you who are newer to mountain biking will have a much greater appreciation for the strong yet lightweight mountain bikes that we have today with disc brakes, suspension, working gears, etc. Like a lot of mountain bikers these days, I ride my rigid singlespeed on trails sometimes for a change of pace from my dual suspension bike. Even that old bike is plush though when compared to the heavy old Klunker bikes with no brakes and components that were not made to handle the abuse. Yep, those guys were tough to race those old bikes downhill, but those heavy old frames and components with a tendency to fail at the worst possible moment provided the incentive for the Marin County riders and others to make the incremental improvements that led to the mountain bikes that we ride today. OK, I am starting to ramble a bit, but really, order the DVD. You won’t be disappointed.

6.23.2008

Cardboard bike

Several readers pointed me to this BBC interview with design student Phil Bridge who designed the $30 recyclable cardboard bike seen here. As Phil points out, “If you make a bicycle from cardboard, no-one will want to steal it!” I guess that is one way to solve the issue of bike theft. You can read more about Phil’s cardboard bike at this quickrelease.tv post.

I noticed that one of the readers who emailed me about the cardboard bike story has an interesting blog about folding bikes. Reed’s Folding Cyclist site might interest some of you, so take a look.

While I am throwing out links, I’ll mention a designboom post about designer Eric Therner’s bike concept for Pilen-Cykel. The design is inspired by retro track bikes, but it has some newer features like integrated LED lights. I assume the fork design provides enough offset for the bike to be rideable, but it looks strange in the picture. Looking at the side view, the hub appears to be directly in line with the steering angle. Who knows though, maybe that is just an illusion due to the fork shape.

Finally, I’ll mention a Copenhagenize post from last week. Apparently, a few designers and a product manager from Trek took a research trip to Europe and met up with Zak, who writes the blog. In addition to Copenhagen, they are visiting Münster, Zürich, and Amsterdam. Sounds like a cool inspiration trip; I’ll look forward to seeing the products that are influenced by it.

6.20.2008

A design award for SRAM

I just received the July/August issue of ID Magazine, the 54th Annual Design Review. This year, a panel of designers from different disciplines reviewed over 2,000 designs and chose the ones to be featured as the best work that was completed or introduced on the market last year. The iPhone took the top spot in the Consumer Products category, but SRAM”s Red group was one of nine other consumer products to be awarded at the Design Distinction level. Congrats to the design team at SRAM for that recognition.

In the Equipment category, the Bikedispenser, designed by John Kock of the Dutch design firm Springtime, was recognized. The Bikedispenser is a fully automated bike rental station that can be found at rail stations in the Netherlands. You just wave a payment card in front of the scanner and a bike rolls out for you to ride. Pretty cool; I would like to see it in person.

Since I brought up SRAM Red group today and the new Dura-Ace group not long ago, I should mention the 2009 Campy Super Record group. Yeah, that’s right Super Record, not just Record. I am glad they are bringing that name back after 20 years. VeloNews has a good write up on the group, so I will just point you to that for further info. Besides, I don’t think I could write anything about the new Campy group without making a Spinal Tap “these go to 11” reference.

Since this is becoming a road bike themed post, I want to point out the new Felt AR that Slipstream-Chipotle riders will be using in the Tour de France next month. As the cyclingnews tech article points out, “the war of bicycle aerodynamics is no longer limited just to time trials.” Make sure that you check out the gallery images of this bike as well.

6.19.2008

Go with me, the Whike, and more

Posting has been light this week, but I want to quickly pass along a few links that I have run across lately. The Core77 blog featured this “electric bike train” concept from the Coroflot portfolio of Jiang Qian. The concept is intended to be modular so the bike can be used individually or strung together. I don’t see any pedals though, so maybe this could more accurately be described as an electric scooter train.

The “Go with me” is just a concept, but for something equally different that is actually in production, check out the Whike, a recumbent tricycle with a big sail attached. Jasper, who pointed this out to me, test rode a Whike for a Dutch newspaper. It sounds like he went pretty fast and had fun riding it; I’d love to try one myself as long as I could get away from traffic to do so.

Speaking of crazy bikes, the people at “Crank it Up Cycling for All” are looking for different types of unusual and fun bike designs that they can build. They are a UK based voluntary non-profit group formed to promote cycling and they offer various types of bikes for people to try out. If any of you have an unusual bike design that you would like to see built, contact them though their website. They can’t pay money for the designs, but they will credit the designer with a sticker on the bike. This seems like a great opportunity for students who wish to see their designs built but don’t have the resources to do so. If any of you submit a design and it gets built, let me know so I can pass along a picture on the blog.

Finally, I’ll mention a post on the new Metropolis magazine blog about a design contest for a bicycle parking garage in Red Hook, Brooklyn. The competition is accepting applications until July 18th. Read more about it here at the Forum for Urban Design website.

6.16.2008

Links and troubleshooting

A reader, Jim, sent me a couple of interesting links that I want to pass along to all of you. The first is an article in Design Engineering magazine about the development and engineering of a Devinci downhill bike. The amount of data they collected to measure forces at various points on the bike is quite impressive. The other article is a good business story about Cervelo. Both articles are worth checking out; thanks Jim.

If you are an industrial designer who wants a job in the bike industry, I want to point out an opportunity to you. Cannondale is looking to add another designer to their team in Bethel, Connecticut. You can read more about the position on Coroflot or on the Cannondale jobs webpage.

Finally, I want to mention a little troubleshooting that I was doing on the blog over the weekend. You may have noticed that I removed a few page elements. I also decreased the number of posts that appear on the main page when the blog loads. I heard from a reader late Friday that Bicycle Design was crashing his browser on the Mac with Safari and on a PC with Explorer. I use Firefox almost exclusively, so I was not aware of a problem with Explorer until I tried it myself and experienced the same problem. Anyway, I tried a few things and though I am definitely no expert on HTML, I believe that the site is now functioning properly. I tested it this morning with Firefox, Explorer, and Opera on the PC and with Safari on a Mac. In all cases, the site seemed to load with no problems. If any of you are still experience problems with Explorer, Safari or any other browser, please do let me know. I want to make sure that Bicycle Design is working for everyone.

6.12.2008

Cable drive transmission

Some of you may recognize this chainless bicycle design. The bike received a lot of press coverage when it was new in the early 80s and was even featured on Good Morning America at one point. The bike’s designer, Steven Tidcomb, sent me a link to a page on his website, which provides some historical background on the design. I also want to share a bit of additional background about the bike from his message:

"It was in limited production in 1982-1983 and manufactured by Creative Motion Industries Inc, of Danvers MA. Only about 60 were sold commercially nationwide before the company closed in 1983. Beyond those 60, I was only able to rescue 8 from the assembly line before the remaining 1500 uncompleted samples were destroyed. I also rescued production quantities of most of it's components and spare parts.

This is a very rare bike. I know of no other available samples of this bicycle beyond the few that I own and the 60 that were sold across the country. Our very first pre-production prototype was actually stolen from our exhibit booth just before our first trade show debut in Boston, in 1982. A $10,000 reward for its return for was posted in the Boston Globe but no one came forward with any information. As you can imagine, it was a significant setback for the company in terms of time, prototype expense, and lost opportunities. There are no other specimens that I can find on display in any bicycle collection or for sale.
"

Steven’s website also mentions a few other possible applications for his cable drive transmission. Out of the ones he mentions, I think the wheelchair or handcycle application has the most potential. Of course, some of you may have other ideas. Steven points out that the US and foreign patents have all expired, so these ideas are now free for anyone to use.

“Perhaps they will inspire other inventors to explore how this technology may be improved and utilized for creations beyond my own.”

Great! Sharing ideas is what this blog is about, so I am happy to point you all to the information about his cable drive transmission. Thanks for sharing it Steven.

6.09.2008

4-dollar gas- a design opportunity?

All morning I have been hearing the news that the U.S. national average for a gallon of gas topped the 4-dollar mark. Most people don’t seem all that happy about that milestone, but climbing gas prices are certainly something you won’t hear me complaining about. In light of the recent attention to 4-dollar gas, I thought I would revisit an old post; specifically my third ever post on this blog from September of 2005. Back then; gas prices were still cheap, but steadily rising, so I mentioned that those climbing prices were a great opportunity for the bike industry. Many commuter oriented bikes and products have hit the US market since that post was written, but I still think that designers in the bike industry have a great opportunity to design products that will introduce cycling to a new segment of the population. I don’t know what the magic number will be for most people, but at some point people will stop just complaining about high gas prices and will take the first step toward changing their driving habits. When they are ready to make that choice, it is important that they see bicycling as not just efficient, but as a fun and healthy way to get around; really a better user experience. It is up to the industry to portray that message, and the design of the products they offer is a big part of it.

For those of us who just love cycling and feel like there is never enough time to ride, it is sometimes hard to think like a “non-cyclist”. That is exactly what designers need to do though if they are to successfully lure new customers out of their cars and onto bicycles. Creating a user experience that is very different from that of the average recreational cyclist is one of the challenges that designers in the industry face. But of course, a challenge means opportunity, so I wanted to reiterate the message in that post from nearly three years ago (nobody was reading the blog back then anyway, so I am sure it is new to most of you).

While I am on this subject, I’ll point you to another post on the subject of gas prices and the industry from Bicycle Marketing Watch (aka Shut Up and Drink the Kool-Aid). It’s an interesting discussion on that site as usual, so check out the post if you missed it.

Photo credit: Fritz/Richard on Flickr

6.06.2008

The G-max blog

Coralie Drouin, an engineer at the French bike company Gir’s, recently sent me a message about a new road bike that they are developing called the G-Max. The bike will be launching in September and they showed a model of the frame at the Salon du Cycle in Paris last year. The company worked with a Parisian design agency to create the frame shape, which I think looks pretty nice. Of course, the design is more than just a styling exercise. Coralie points out that they have patented several innovations on the frame, notably the BB system, which allows the user to change the location of the BB spindle.

The frame renderings immediately caught my attention, but what really interested me when I read the message was the fact that Gir’s has a blog about the development of the G-max. It is pretty cool to be able to read about the evolution of this bike from just an idea to a real product. I appreciate the fact that Gir’s is offering a glimpse into their product development process. Companies are usually very secretive about products that they have in development. They want to shield their ideas from competitors until the very last minute, but a blog like this is a great way to build excitement about a product before it is officially launched. I hope that it works out for Gir’s with the new G-Max. Thanks to Coralie for the message and the great product development blog.

6.05.2008

Interview in BikeBiz

I usually refrain from posting pictures of myself, but I will make an exception today. Here I am looking very serious while working hard to bring you the absolute best content that I can find on the subject of bicycle design. OK, maybe that is a stretch, but this picture of me staring blankly at my computer screen does accompany an interview that can be found in the June issue of Bike Biz, the UK based magazine for “everyone in the bicycle business”. The pdf version of the June issue does not seem to be available for download yet, but you can read a short version of Carlton Reid’s interview with me on the Bike Biz website.

Update 6/10: the full print version of the June issue is now available to download right here.

Carlton also mentioned one question from the interview on a Quickrelease.tv post, so check that one out as well. While you are at Quickrelease.tv, take a look at the pictures he posted from his recent family bike trip to Scotland. My two oldest kids are about the same age as Carlton’s, so I was pretty impressed to read about his family's daily mileage over rough terrain. Sounds tough, but it also sounds like it was a great trip for all of them; I’d love to do a family bike trip like that once my youngest is a little older.

6.03.2008

Dwell, the Trailcart, and a challenge

I like to mention bike content in general design magazines when I see it, so I want to point you to a Dwell blog post about handmade bicycles. The post dates back to February, but it was new to me when I discovered it today, so I assume some of you missed it as well. The rear dropout shown here from a Vanilla road bike is just one of the detail shots you will see in the post.

The Trailcart has been spreading around the web since it appeared on Treehugger and Gizmodo. This pedal powered vehicle with independent four-wheel drive was designed by hobbyist Frank Fraune of Germany. The machine, which uses a Shimano Nexus 8 speed transmission, has up to 400mm of axle displacement. After looking at the pictures on the Treehugger post and in the Trailcart Gallery, all I can say is that I would love to try this thing out. If I did get a chance to ride it though, I would probably leave my team kit in the closet.

Ari of the Bits and Bikes blog has a question/challenge for all you designers and engineers who might be reading: Can you build a fixed-effort bicycle? The idea, which he is calling “NuFixie”, is to build up a bike that uses the NuVinci CVP hub, while controlling the gear ratio automatically based on sensor input measuring chain tension. He is looking for feedback, so leave a comment here or at his post if you have anything to say about his idea or about any other constant effort bicycle transmission concept. His post makes me want to go back and review the discussion of nonpositive drives and variable automatic transmissions in “Bicycling Science”. That book is always a great source on such subjects, but it worth keeping in mind that quite a bit has happened since the 80s. Some ideas that were not really practical at the time may become more feasible as new technologies emerge. In other words, don’t rule an idea out just because of obstacles in past attempts to make it work.

6.02.2008

Dura-Ace 7900

I don’t have time for a full post today, but I want to quickly mention the new 2009 redesign of the Dura-Ace group. Overall, I think the 7900 series Dura Ace group looks good; I especially like the new brakes. The new crank, which includes a compact option, looks nice as well. I like the way the crank arm flows into the chainring, but it might take me a while to get used to the new Dura-Ace crank, which looks like it took a few cues from XTR. I loved the 7800 series Dura-Ace crank when that design debuted about 5 years ago, so I consider that one a tough crank to improve on (speaking strictly about aesthetics).

The total weight of around 2000 grams is lighter than the previous Dura-Ace group, but still heavier than SRAM Red. I imagine the popularity of the Red group was a big consideration with this redesign from Shimano, which includes carbon fiber on the rear derailleur and shifter/brake levers. Speaking of the shifter levers, something else that I am happy to finally see is the rerouting of the shifter cables under the bar tape. That is one detail where Shimano has been trailing Campy and other competitors for quite some time.

If you are interested, read more about the new Dura-Ace group here, here, and here.